How much plant do you build for an uncertain feed?

Choose a reliable measurement floor and an illustrative design factor. Watch the design basis change, then test what happens when equipment comes in fixed sizes.

Teaching model
Sensor floor, sample, chosen design basis and relative equipment capacityWhat sits below the reliable floor?Unwanted material in the feed (%)051015202530Sample 4.9%: below the quantitation floor5.0% floor × 2.0 chosen factor = 10.0% basisTank volumeFilter areaCapacity vs original100%Dashed: original sizeIllustrative sizing. Quantitation floor ≠ detection limit or uncertainty.

Enlarge for bigger labels, then swipe sideways →

Chosen design basis10.0 %
Capacity vs original100 %
Sample measurementBelow floor

5.0% × 2.0 = 10.0% design basis under this invented rule. With continuous sizing, capacity is 100% of the original 10% basis. The 4.9% sample is below the chosen quantitation floor; being below it does not establish zero contamination.

What this model assumes

Every number is illustrative. We choose design basis (%) = quantitation floor (%) × chosen factor, and capacity proportional to this load. A factor of two is not a standard or a justified design decision for a real plant. The original comparison is a 5% floor with factor 2, giving 10%; relative capacity always uses that fixed 10% baseline. Discrete mode rounds capacity upward in fictional 2-percentage-point steps. A quantitation floor is the lowest amount reliably quantified; a lower amount may still be detected. It is not a standard uncertainty or a hard threshold at which all signals disappear. JCGM guard bands involve measurement uncertainty and decision risk; they do not derive this invented floor-times-factor rule. Flow variation, kinetics, fouling, turndown, equipment cost curves, sensor cost and operating options are omitted.

Better measurements can change a design basis; the margin still needs engineering judgment.

A result below a quantitation limit cannot be quantified with the required precision and accuracy. It may still be detected. Calling it zero would lose information; it also does not mean every low sample produces exactly the same sensor signal.

For this invented example, choose a design basis equal to the quantitation floor multiplied by a chosen factor. A 5% floor and factor 2 give 10%. A 2% floor with the same factor gives 4%. With capacity directly proportional to this load, that is 40% of the original capacity, a 60% reduction.

The factor and proportional sizing rule are teaching choices. NASA describes margins as allowances for uncertainties and risks. JCGM describes decision guard bands using measurement uncertainty and risk; a quantitation limit is a different quantity. Neither source prescribes multiplying a sensor floor by two to size a process.

Real decisions also depend on flow variation, kinetics, fouling, turndown and operating strategy. Equipment comes in discrete sizes and its cost need not scale with capacity. The optional 2-point size steps here are fictional.

Under this lesson’s chosen rule, an 8% floor and factor 1.5 give what basis, and what if the floor improves to 4%?

Taking a real process
beyond the lab?

Jon and I are building RARE Labs toward an autonomous pilot plant builder using AI and robotics. Join the waitlist for updates, and tell us what you’re trying to scale.

Join the RARE Labs waitlist ↗

Go a little deeper.