Heat & energy / INTERACTIVE LESSON 36
Detonation versus deflagration: when a flame outruns sound
The line between an ordinary fire and a detonation is the speed of sound in the gas ahead of the flame, about 340 metres per second in air. Slower than that, the flame is a deflagration. Faster, a shock wave locks onto the flame and it is a detonation.
CHANGE A CONDITION. SEE WHAT FOLLOWS.
Teaching modelEnlarge for bigger labels, then swipe sideways →
A 10 m/s flame in dry air at 15 °C is at Mach 0.03, below the 340 m/s speed of sound in the gas ahead of it. That makes it a deflagration: sound runs ahead of the flame, and the flame alone sets the pace.
What this model assumes
Teaching model, not a hazard assessment. The speed of sound in the unburned gas is a = √(γRT/M), with R = 8.314 J/(mol·K) and T in kelvin. Dry air uses γ = 1.40 and M = 0.02896 kg/mol, so a = 340 m/s at 15 °C (288.15 K). The fuel and air rows are stoichiometric mixtures (9.5 percent methane, 4.0 percent propane, 29.5 percent hydrogen by volume) with mole-fraction averages of molar mass and room-temperature heat-capacity ratio: methane and air γ = 1.39, M = 0.02774; propane and air γ = 1.37, M = 0.02957; hydrogen and air γ = 1.40, M = 0.02101. γ is held constant as the temperature changes. Mach number = front speed ÷ a. A front below Mach 1 is called a deflagration and a front above Mach 1 a detonation, as the CSB report footnote defines them. A steady detonation in a hydrocarbon vapour cloud travels at roughly 1,800 m/s, so a front only just above Mach 1 has not yet reached that speed. Obstacles raise flame speed through added turbulence. The run-up rule here is illustrative, not a fitted correlation: the flame doubles its speed every metre from the speed on the slider, so run-up = 1 m × log₂(a ÷ speed). The picture is drawn with 52 px for each metre. The model ignores gas composition effects on detonability, confinement, cloud size, dust, and solids such as ammonium nitrate, and the fact that a flame seen from outside moves faster than its burning velocity because burned gas expands. Slider positions are preferred numbers spaced evenly on a log scale from 1 to 3,000 m/s.
THE IDEA TO TAKE WITH YOU
An explosion becomes a detonation when the front outruns the speed of sound in the gas ahead of it, and clutter such as pipes and trees can push a flame there.
Sound is a pressure signal, and its speed in a gas depends on the gas and its temperature: a = √(γRT/M), where γ is the heat-capacity ratio, R the gas constant, T the absolute temperature and M the molar mass. In dry air at 15 °C that is about 340 metres per second.
A flame slower than the speed of sound in the gas ahead of it is a deflagration. Sound runs ahead of it, and the flame creeps along at a few metres per second. A front faster than sound is a detonation. A shock wave squeezes the gas hot enough to ignite, and the burning feeds the shock, so the two travel together. In a hydrocarbon vapour cloud a detonation moves at roughly 1,800 metres per second.
Divide the front's speed by the speed of sound and you get the Mach number. A 10 metre per second flame in air is at Mach 0.03. A 1,800 metre per second front is at Mach 5.3. Mach 1 is the line between the two.
Clutter pushes a flame toward that line. Pipes, racks and even a line of trees stir the gas, the flame speeds up, shocks build ahead of it, and the mixture can detonate. The obstacle setting here uses an illustrative rule, a flame that doubles its speed every metre, only to show the idea. Real distances depend on the fuel, the obstacles, the confinement and the size of the cloud.
Two public reports describe real events. At Buncefield, a UK fuel depot, in 2005, investigators think a flame in a petrol vapour cloud may have sped up through a line of trees and detonated. 43 people were injured, none seriously, and no one died. At West, Texas, in 2013, about 30 tons of ammonium nitrate detonated. 15 people died and more than 260 were injured. The Buncefield mechanism was debated, and ammonium nitrate is a solid, so the model here does not describe either event.
QUICK CHECK
A flame front travels at 100 metres per second through a gas where sound travels at 340 metres per second. Is it a deflagration or a detonation, and what would have to change for the other answer?
FROM UNDERSTANDING TO BUILDING
Taking a real process
beyond the lab?
Jon and I are building RARE Labs toward an autonomous pilot plant builder using AI and robotics. Join the waitlist for updates, and tell us what you’re trying to scale.
FOLLOW THE EVIDENCE
Go a little deeper.
- U.S. Chemical Safety and Hazard Investigation BoardFinal investigation report on the 2013 explosion at West, Texas ↗
Defines deflagration and detonation against the speed of sound in a footnote, and gives the detonation of about 30 tons of ammonium nitrate, 15 deaths and more than 260 injuries.
- Buncefield Major Incident Investigation BoardInitial report ↗
Defines a deflagration by flame speed against the speed of sound, about 340 metres per second, with deflagration at a few metres per second.
- Buncefield Major Incident Investigation BoardFinal report, volume 2a ↗
Gives the 43 injuries, none of them serious, and no deaths.
- Buncefield Major Incident Investigation BoardFinal report, volume 2b ↗
Reports that the advisory group found no single scenario for how the explosion developed.
- Joint industry projectReport on the Buncefield explosion mechanism (2011) ↗
Judges a transition from a fast flame to a detonation in the tree line to be the likely route.
- Progress in Energy and Combustion Science (Oran, Chamberlain and Pekalski 2020)Mechanisms and occurrence of detonations in vapor cloud explosions ↗
Gives roughly 1,800 metres per second for detonations in hydrocarbon vapour clouds and reviews how obstacles lead to detonation.