Everyday physics / INTERACTIVE LESSON 28
The spooky fog is not the CO₂
Immersed dry ice makes CO₂ bubbles; the white mist starts as water vapor from the surrounding bulk water.
CHANGE A CONDITION. SEE WHAT FOLLOWS.
Teaching modelEnlarge for bigger labels, then swipe sideways →
While the bubble remains in contact with cold dry ice, water vapor inside it condenses into tiny liquid droplets. The droplets make the bubble look foggy.
What this model assumes
Qualitative teaching storyboard based on Kuntzleman et al., Journal of Chemical Education (2015), DOI 10.1021/ed400754n. For dry ice immersed in water, submerged CO₂(s) sublimes into a CO₂(g) bubble. Molecules from the bulk water evaporate into that bubble and, while it remains in contact with the cold dry ice, condense as tiny liquid droplets inside it. The fog-filled bubble separates, rises, and bursts at the surface, releasing the mist. This is a proposed mechanism, not a temperature, rate, or amount model. It does not teach ambient-air moisture as the source of the immersed-water fog. This is an explanation, not an activity guide: never seal dry ice in a container; use suitable supervision, ventilation, and handling.
THE IDEA TO TAKE WITH YOU
The bubble carries water mist, not visible CO₂.
Submerged dry ice sublimes into bubbles of colorless CO₂ gas.
Molecules from the bulk water evaporate into the bubble. While it remains in contact with cold dry ice, the water vapor condenses into tiny liquid droplets inside the bubble.
The fog-filled bubble separates, rises to the surface, and bursts to release its water mist. In this immersed-water demonstration, ambient-air moisture is not the primary source of the fog.
This is a qualitative explanation, not an activity guide. Never seal dry ice in a container; use suitable supervision, ventilation, and handling.
QUICK CHECK
In a dry-ice-in-water demonstration, what is the proposed source of the water in the dense fog?
FROM UNDERSTANDING TO BUILDING
Taking a real process
beyond the lab?
Jon and I are building RARE Labs toward an autonomous pilot plant builder using AI and robotics. Join the waitlist for updates, and tell us what you’re trying to scale.
FOLLOW THE EVIDENCE
Go a little deeper.
- American Chemical SocietySolid carbon dioxide and phase change ↗
Supports the phase-change distinction: solid CO₂ sublimes directly to CO₂ gas at ordinary atmospheric pressure.
- Journal of Chemical EducationA Molecular Explanation of How the Fog Is Produced when Dry Ice Is Placed in Water ↗
Reports that fog water originates from the bulk liquid; proposes vaporizing into CO₂ bubbles, condensing while bubbles contact dry ice, then rising and bursting.