Thermodynamics / INTERACTIVE LESSON 07

Why can’t an engine use all the heat?

Change two reservoir temperatures and watch the ideal work/heat split.

CHANGE A CONDITION. SEE WHAT FOLLOWS.

Teaching model
Carnot heat-engine energy balanceAt 600 K and 300 K, the reversible efficiency limit is 50 percent. Arrows are schematic, not scaled to heat flow.One heat input. Two destinations.Hot reservoir600 KReversiblelimitQh = 100 kJWork out50 kJQc = 50 kJCold: 300 K100 kJ in = 50 kJ work + 50 kJ rejected

Enlarge for bigger labels, then swipe sideways →

Carnot efficiency ceiling50 %
Work output per cycle50 kJ
Heat rejected per cycle50 kJ
Heat supplied per cycle100 kJ

Using kelvin, η = 1 − 300/600 = 50%. Of the 100 kJ supplied, at most 50 kJ becomes work in this reversible model; 50 kJ must be rejected. The reservoir entropy changes cancel: −Qh/Th + Qc/Tc = 0. Irreversibilities reduce real performance. The arrows show the energy routes, not proportional flow widths.

What this model assumes

Ideal reversible heat-engine limit between two constant-temperature reservoirs. All temperatures are absolute kelvin. Qh and Qc are positive heat-transfer magnitudes per cycle, and W = Qh − Qc. η = 1 − Tc/Th is a ceiling, not a prediction of a real engine or its power. Equal reservoir temperatures show the zero-work limiting balance, not a working heat engine.

THE IDEA TO TAKE WITH YOU

Even an ideal reversible heat engine has to reject heat when its cold reservoir is above absolute zero.

A heat engine absorbs heat from a hot reservoir, produces work and rejects the remaining heat to a colder reservoir.

The reversible Carnot limit is 1 − Tc/Th, using absolute temperatures in kelvin.

Real engines have additional losses. Their efficiency is below the reversible bound for the same two reservoir temperatures.

QUICK CHECK

Can you put Celsius temperatures directly into the Carnot ratio?

FROM THE VIDEO: THE CELSIUS TRAP, PHYSICS’ CUT, AND WHICH LEVER IS STRONGER

Kelvin. Always Kelvin.

Ideal ceiling50.0 %
Work out30 J
The second law’s cut50 J
Irreversibility’s cut20 J

Physics takes its cut.

Send 100 J into a cyclic heat engine. The dashed line is the ideal bound, 1 − Tc/Th of the input: it is set by the two reservoirs and does not move with this slider. Real engines land to its left, because real processes are irreversible.

Two reservoirs, one ratio.

A cyclic heat engine between a hot and a cold reservoir cannot beat η = 1 − Tc/Th, with both temperatures in kelvin. The video’s illustrative pair, 600 K and 300 K, gives 50 %: of 100 J entering, at most 50 J becomes work and at least 50 J must be rejected. Set the two reservoirs; everything on this card follows from them.

The Celsius trap.

Kelvin, the right way50.0 %1 − 300/600
Celsius, the trap91.7 %1 − 27/327

Plugging in 327 °C and 27 °C gives 1 − 27/327 = 91.7 %, which is false. The ratio only means something on an absolute scale: 0 °C is not zero thermal energy.

Which lever is stronger?

Raise the hot side by 50 K+3.8 pts
Lower the cold side by 50 K+8.3 pts

What this assumes

A cyclic heat engine operating between two constant-temperature reservoirs; the bound does not apply to every energy converter (a fuel cell or a solar cell is not a heat engine). Temperatures are absolute; the Celsius card uses the rounded 273 offset so the video’s 327 °C and 27 °C come out exactly. The effectiveness slider is an illustrative second-law effectiveness: actual work divided by the reversible maximum. The two legs of a Carnot cycle that are not isothermal are reversible adiabatic, which is to say isentropic. The 600 K and 300 K pair is a teaching example, not a measured machine, and nothing here predicts power or cost.

Sources: TU Delft, Entropy and Heat Engines ↗ · MIT Unified Engineering, The Carnot Cycle ↗ · OpenStax, Carnot’s Perfect Heat Engine ↗

FROM UNDERSTANDING TO BUILDING

Taking a real process
beyond the lab?

Jon and I are building RARE Labs toward an autonomous pilot plant builder. Join the waitlist for updates, and tell us what you’re trying to scale.

Join the RARE Labs waitlist ↗

FOLLOW THE EVIDENCE

Go a little deeper.