Separations / INTERACTIVE LESSON 11
How do you push water out of salt water?
Balance applied pressure against osmotic pressure across an ideal selective membrane.
CHANGE A CONDITION. SEE WHAT FOLLOWS.
Teaching modelEnlarge for bigger labels, then swipe sideways →
Applied pressure exceeds the opposing osmotic difference by 25 bar, so the calculated flux points toward the dilute side. This is the reverse-osmosis direction; it is not a prediction of potable-water output or rejection performance.
What this model assumes
Toy linear water-flux relation J = A(ΔP − Δπ). Positive flux means water moving from the concentrated side toward the dilute side. Δπ is an independently chosen effective osmotic-pressure difference across an idealized selective membrane. A is an illustrative constant, not a measured membrane specification. This does not predict a seawater plant: salt passage, concentration polarization, changing concentration, fouling, pressure losses and recovery are omitted.
THE IDEA TO TAKE WITH YOU
A membrane creates selectivity. A driving force determines which way water moves.
At equal applied pressure, water tends to move toward the more concentrated solution through a membrane that passes water but rejects solute.
Apply enough opposing pressure and net water transport reverses. The simplified water-flux relation is J = A(ΔP − Δπ).
A desalination plant produces permeate and concentrate. Real membranes have imperfect rejection, concentration polarization and operating constraints.
QUICK CHECK
At ΔP = Δπ, what does this simplified model predict?
FROM THE VIDEO: THE NET ARROW FLIPS
Two crossings, one net.
Where the salt goes.
Water goes both ways. The net is the difference.
The membrane lets water pass much more easily than dissolved salt, and water crosses it in both directions all the time. Each side sends water across at a rate its own salt lowers and applied pressure raises. Put fresher water on one side and saltier water on the other at the same pressure and the saltier side sends less back, so the net points toward the saltier side: that is osmosis, and it is the wrong way round if you want fresh water out of seawater. Pressurize the salty side until the two rates match and the net is exactly zero. Push past that and the net flips: water goes against its usual net direction, and the salt mostly stays behind.
Rejected, not erased.
Most of the salt is rejected, but it does not disappear. Feed the membrane a litre at a time: a share of the water (the recovery) leaves as lower-salt permeate, the rest leaves as concentrate, and every gram of salt that came in is in one of the two outgoing streams. Rejection is the share of the feed salt kept out of the permeate, and it is never total.
The crossing rates are an illustration of the idea, not a measured membrane: the lab above keeps the usual one-line form, J = A(ΔP − Δπ), and this section only unpacks its sign as a difference of two crossings. Nothing on this page says whether any stream is safe to drink.
What this assumes
Two well-mixed compartments at the same temperature, separated by an ideal membrane that passes water and holds back salt. Osmotic pressure is taken as 0.75 bar per gram of salt per litre, a teaching approximation (35 g/L comes out at 26.25 bar, near seawater). Each side sends water across at a baseline rate lowered by its own osmotic pressure and raised by its applied pressure, so the net is their difference, Δπ − P, which has the same sign rule as the lab’s J = A(ΔP − Δπ) with positive taken here as toward the saltier side. Real pressure must also overcome flow losses through the membrane, its spacers and the piping, and salt builds up at the membrane face, so a real plant runs well above the hold point: the simple diagram isolates the osmotic effect. The ledger uses rejection as one minus the permeate salt divided by the feed salt, per litre fed, and caps it below 100 % because real membranes do not reject 100 % of every dissolved substance. Nothing here is a measure of water quality or a statement that any stream is safe to drink.
Sources: OpenStax Chemistry 2e, 11.4 Colligative Properties ↗ · USGS, Reverse Osmosis Desalination ↗ · MIT OCW 2.500, Membrane Processes ↗
FROM UNDERSTANDING TO BUILDING
Taking a real process
beyond the lab?
Jon and I are building RARE Labs toward an autonomous pilot plant builder. Join the waitlist for updates, and tell us what you’re trying to scale.
FOLLOW THE EVIDENCE
Go a little deeper.
- OpenStax / Rice UniversityChemistry 2e 11.4 Colligative Properties ↗
Ordinary osmosis direction at equal external pressure; osmotic pressure; reversing solvent transport by greater opposing pressure.
- US Geological SurveyReverse Osmosis Desalination ↗
Pressure-driven water transport through a selective membrane and rejection of most dissolved salt.
- MIT OpenCourseWare 2.500Membrane Processes ↗
Pressure overcomes osmotic pressure, creating permeate and concentrate; energy and membrane selectivity matter.